ObamaCare Is Not Insurance

Food, clothing, shelter and health care are not guaranteed citizen rights under the

Robert R. Livingston

Image via Wikipedia

Constitution or the Declaration of Independence, but only “life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness”.  Nevertheless, as of last month ObamaCare appears to have become, along with Medicare and Medicaid, an entitlement for almost everyone.

The concept of “insurance” is that everyone in a group shares risk so that the burden of the unfortunate is reduced and the lucky ones gain peace of mind.  For insurance to work as it should, its cost should be competitive so that the consumer can make a free choice between risk and coverage.  But the current system is not really insurance.  It covers “pre-existing

Spending on U.S. healthcare as a percentage of...

Image via Wikipedia

conditions” and places no limit on demand.  Under government-subsidized insurance, patients pay little or nothing extra for additional consultations, tests and services.  Therefore it is not insurance, it is socialism.  The health-care industry, which just like any other business seeks growth above all else, is eager to respond to unlimited demand by providing facilities, personnel, motorized carts, and an endless stream of medications and sophisticated test and monitoring equipment for every perceived need.

Congress should have approved a plan that requires the patient to pay something significant for the treatment sought, that is, enough to give incentives to shop for care and to stop self-abusive behaviors (e.g., smoking, obesity, sloth).  It did not.  The future of American healthcare is therefore predictable, because limited resources can not support unlimited demand.  Great Britain has such a system.  One of their physicians writes that, “. . . Britain does have the dirtiest, most broken-down hospitals in Europe.”  (WSJ, 7/29/2009, p. A13)

There is irony in this situation because the solution to most of the healthcare problems in this country is relatively cheap.  Let me give you a real-life example.  Someone near to me recently, over a period of about 9 months, intentionally lost 24% of her weight.  She did it, not through extreme dieting, but through portion-control and exercise.  She

Two young girls jog along Morro Strand State Beach

Image by mikebaird via Flickr

walks at least 2 miles a day, every day.  She still eats pizza, french fries and steak along with her fruits and vegetables, although she has cut out sugar and most starches.  Her type II diabetes is gone.  So is her sleep apnea.  Her blood pressure is nearly normal (previously through the roof) and her cholesterol has also normalized.  Her foot problems cleared up also. This was a cheap fix.

Changes like this, plus avoiding smoking and excessive drinking, are in my opinion much more effective than any pill.  It is not surprising that pharmaceutical ads dominate television because we love to believe that pills can substitute for will power, but the press is full of health problems and lawsuits over side effects.

It is interesting to note a recent report about President Obama’s annual physical.  He

UW Medical Center PET-CT-Scan

Image via Wikipedia

chose to have a virtual CT scan in place of a standard colonoscopy, ostensibly so he would not have to go under anesthetic.  (Flash, Mr. President: the Cold War is over!)  This was not only more expensive, but it subjected him to a large dose of unnecessary radiation.  Incidentally, had any problem been seen in the scan, he would have had to undergo the colonoscopy also.  This is not a good example for the populace.  How many of us will now avoid the trouble and unpleasantness of the regular test, at no additional cost?  CT and MRI machines are among the most expensive types of medical equipment and, once installed, must be used extensively to justify their purchase.

It would have been possible to design a healthcare system that gave people an incentive to correct their lifestyles, and a disincentive to seek unnecessary tests, medicines and procedures.  This is called “paying for some of it yourself”.  Too bad.   We have chosen more government, not less, because we can not stand to see anyone in need, even if it’s their own fault.

Watch out, here comes the bill, and it’s going to be a whopper!

About Jim Wheeler

U. S. Naval Academy, BS, Engineering, 1959; Naval line officer and submariner, 1959 -1981, Commander, USN; The George Washington U., MSA, Management Eng.; Aerospace Engineer, 1981-1999; Resident Gadfly, 1999 - present. Political affiliation: Democratic.
This entry was posted in Fiscal Policy and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to ObamaCare Is Not Insurance

  1. ansonburlingame says:


    thanks for the link to your blog, a good one. Why don’t you get listed as such on the Globe blog page? Email Carol (cstark@joplinglobe.com) and request such.

    Your position of implenting consumer control of health care spending is right on the mark. I love the Obmaa CT scan example. In yesteryear if I was ill I would call or go to my doctor including weekends or after hours if it was really serious. I was the one to determine “seriousness” and my doctor always was there to respond.

    What do we now hear all the time today. “Go to the emergency room because the doctor is “booked up” for three weeks”. So a $100 doctor visit turns into a $4000 emergency room visit. Who pays? All of us!!!! And more and more examples might be given.

    Pending your addition to the Globe blog page, I have checked the notify me by email box for new posts below. Keep up the good work.

    Should I assume you were USNA Class of 1959?. I was in “65.



    • Jim Wheeler says:


      Thanks for the vote of confidence. You can tell I’m new at this, but it is interesting.

      Yes, USNA ’59. I was in the 19th Company, 5th Batt. I had a wildly varied career, retired after 22 as O-5. I look forward to blogging with you and the others, whomever they may be.



  2. Geoff Caldwell says:

    Excellent article and points made. The biggest fear I have is that so many Americans today have become so “entitlement” minded that they just expect the rest of us to pay for them. And as long as Obama, Pelosi and Reid have control they’ll just keep dishing it out for future votes. The country and the citizens actually PAYING the taxes be damned.
    I knew Obama was lying through his teeth during the campaign but I never dreamed he’d actually succeed with so much of his agenda. I so greatly underestimated the number of spines in Congress.
    Keep the insight coming.


    • Jim Wheeler says:


      I had not read your blog before today. It appears that we have much in common, particularly from your self-description in the “About the Author” section. Like Anson, I do not profess certainty about very much. Economics deserves its designation as the “dismal science”, except that it ain’t science yet. Nevertheless, like you, I can’t ignore the obvious errors in general direction.

      Thanks for the kind comment. I look forward to blogging with you and the others.

      Jim Wheeler


  3. wingwiper says:

    Coming in on this lately, Amen, and AMEN!


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.